Why You Should Choose a Scar Cream Over a Scar Gel
When it comes to treating scars, the sheer number of products available can feel overwhelming. Two of the most common types are scar creams and scar gels. While both are designed to improve the appearance of scars, their formulations and the benefits they provide are vastly different. Understanding these differences can help you make an informed choice and ultimately lead to better results for your skin.
The Basics: Gels vs. Creams
Scar gels are typically water-based products. They are lightweight, fast-absorbing, and often leave little to no residue on the skin. Their main ingredients usually include silicone, which forms a protective barrier over the scar, preventing water loss and creating the ideal environment for healing. Scar gels are great for those who prefer a non-greasy feel and are particularly effective at improving the appearance of newer scars by keeping them hydrated and reducing itchiness.
Scar creams, on the other hand, are emulsions containing both water and oils. This difference in formulation makes creams richer and more nourishing compared to gels. Alongside hydrating ingredients, scar creams often include natural oils, butters, and other actives that provide deeper moisturization and deliver nutrients to the skin. The inclusion of oils makes creams particularly effective for addressing older or more stubborn scars, where the skin might require extra support to repair itself.
Why Oils Matter in Scar Healing
Oils in scar creams play a crucial role in the healing process, offering benefits that water-based gels alone cannot provide. Here’s why:
-
Deep Hydration:
Oils are occlusive agents, meaning they help lock in moisture and prevent transepidermal water loss (TEWL). This is especially important for scarred skin, which tends to lose moisture more easily. Well-hydrated skin is more elastic, which reduces tightness around the scar and promotes smoother healing. -
Nourishment:
Many oils are rich in essential fatty acids, antioxidants, and vitamins like A, E, and C, which are vital for skin repair. For example, rosehip oil contains vitamin A (retinoids), known to promote cell turnover, while jojoba oil mimics the skin's natural sebum, ensuring the scar tissue stays soft and pliable. -
Soothing Properties:
Scars can sometimes be itchy, irritated, or inflamed. Oils like calendula, chamomile, or almond oil have natural anti-inflammatory properties that help calm these symptoms, making scar creams a comforting option for sensitive or healing skin. -
Improved Barrier Function:
Oils help strengthen the skin’s natural barrier, protecting the scarred area from environmental stressors like pollution or bacteria that could hinder the healing process. -
Enhanced Collagen Production:
Some oils, like argan or coconut oil, are known to boost collagen synthesis, which is essential for repairing damaged skin and improving scar texture over time.
When to Use a Scar Cream vs. a Scar Gel
Scar gels are a good choice for fresh scars, especially if they are in exposed areas like the face or hands, where a lightweight, non-greasy product is preferred. Their quick-drying nature makes them easy to use during the day or under makeup. Silicone-based gels, in particular, are excellent for creating a protective barrier and helping scars heal smoothly.
Scar creams, however, shine when it comes to older, tougher scars or areas prone to dryness, like the knees, elbows, or surgical scars. The oils in scar creams provide deeper hydration and nourishment, which is essential for addressing thicker or raised scars such as keloids or hypertrophic scars. Creams are also ideal for use at night, allowing the skin to absorb the rich ingredients while it repairs itself during sleep.
Making the Right Choice for Your Skin
While both scar gels and creams have their merits, the key to choosing the right product lies in understanding your specific needs. If you’re looking for lightweight hydration and a product that works well for newer scars, a gel might be the right choice. However, if your scars are older, larger, or in need of extra moisture and nourishment, a cream is likely to deliver better results.
Additionally, consider your skin type and lifestyle. If you have dry skin, the oils in scar creams can provide the hydration your skin craves. If you prefer a matte finish or need a product that won’t interfere with your daily routine, a gel may suit you better.
The Bottom Line
Scar healing isn’t a one-size-fits-all process, and the choice between a cream and a gel can make all the difference in achieving the best results. While gels provide hydration and protection, creams go a step further by deeply nourishing the skin, supporting its natural repair process, and improving overall texture. By choosing a scar cream, you’re opting for a solution that not only improves the appearance of scars but also enhances the health and resilience of your skin.
